We offer a variety of insurance options to our clients including

Home Insurance
Your home is a huge investment, protect it. We can help you make sure that everything will be taken care of. Contact us today to see how we can protect one of your biggest investments.
Auto Insurance

Overwhelmed by all the auto insurance choices? Don’t be. We can make finding the right car insurance plan easy. Let us help you find the plan you need at a rate you can afford.

Business Insurance

Our experts can go over your business model and let you know about all the different business insurance plans and how each kind works for you best.


Satisfied Clients


Companies Represented


Policy Options


Dedicated to Your Needs

Who we are

Independent Agents, to better suit you.

We at Tartan Insurance Agency, Inc. are an independent insurance agency that represents multiple insurance companies. We do not work for the insurance companies, we work for you, our client. Every client’s situation is different. Therefore, their needs are different. Our goal is to address those needs and provide outstanding customer service and develop long term relationships with our clients.

Tartan Insurance is licensed as an independent agent in Wisconsin, Illinois and Michigan. We represent many highly rated insurance companies and are able to place you with the right company that meets your current needs.
We dedicate ourselves to providing some of the most competitive options for clients in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Michigan in the following lines of coverage:

  • Auto & Motorcycle
  • Home
  • Rentals
  • Seasonals
  • Recreational Vehicles
  • Umbrella Coverage
  • Commercial Liability
  • Commercial Property
  • Commercial Auto
  • Inland Marine
  • Worker's Compensation

Tartan Insurance is an active member of the Independent Insurance Agents of Wisconsin, a professional insurance trade association dedicated to serving the needs of more than 5,000 member agents, staff members and their customers.

The team at Tartan Insurance is committed to being ethical and having integrity. We understand that situations happen and that having the right policy and coverage can make all the difference.

Make sure your business, family, and other assets are protected with the proper coverage. Contact us today at (920) 494-7421 for a quote and see how much you can improve and save on your premiums!

Make sure your business, family, and other assets are protected.

Contact us today at (920) 494-7421 for a quote and see how much you can improve and save on your premiums!


Request a quote with our quick and easy form!

Todd Pliner

Owner - Tartan Insurance

Todd has been with Tartan Insurance Agency, Inc. since 1987. He purchased the agency in 2000. He specializes in Commercial, Personal Lines, and Life Insurance.